Use the St. Johns County Property Appraiser record to pin down the parcel ID, then pull recorded documents from the Clerk of Circuit Court. Save the deed and legal description alongside mortgages, releases, liens, easements, community documents, and the assessed improvements. Because the county permit process also uses the parcel ID, keeping that identifier consistent prevents records from being attached to a similar address. Confirm whether County Building, St. Augustine, or St. Augustine Beach has jurisdiction. Neither tax data nor a recorded deed proves final approval of a roof, lanai, pool, addition, seawall, electrical replacement, or change in occupancy.
Request permits, plans, inspection results, certificates, and code history from the responsible office. County floodplain guidance states that development within a special flood hazard area requires a construction permit. Keep elevation certificates, substantial-improvement or damage records, claims, wind reports, dated photographs, and storm invoices. A coastal or historic property may need additional local, state, or federal review. For private systems, collect septic approvals, pumping and repairs, well tests, and utility-conversion information. Check association and CDD assessments outside the public building file.
Compare what you would receive from each route using the same evidence. A listing could require flood or historic coordination, permit closeout, storm repairs, septic work, cleanup, showings, and continuing insurance, taxes, utilities, dues, district assessments, and financing. An as-is proposal may reduce how much construction you need to handle before closing but still needs review of inspections, cancellation rights, buyer assignment, title conditions, charges, closing date, and possession. Estates, tenants, vacation use, or multiple owners can complicate access. Address active moisture, unsafe systems, and confirmed approval gaps before broad cosmetic improvements.
Compare selling options →